Largest Insurers Fail to Optimize for Local Search Opportunities

The way consumers shop for insurance has changed. Today's consumer is mobile-first and digitally-driven. 71% of consumers turn to digital channels to do…

Custom keyboard with insurance key highlighted

Translated by

Keep us in your search resultsAdd us as a preferred source on Google

Any Insurance Carrier Willing to Invest in a Proximity Search Strategy Could Dominate

The way consumers shop for insurance has changed. Today's consumer is mobile-first and digitally-driven. In fact, 71% of consumers turn to digital channels to do research before buying insurance, according to a recent PWC insurance survey. This doesn't mean that consumers are going directly to your website either. On the contrary, 85% of consumers find local business information through an internet search online, where reviews and maps are just a click away, according to a Nielsen study.

Most consumers consult Google and use unbranded search terms like "affordable car insurance," or "best rate insurance." These searches factor in the user's proximity to local businesses, whether or not they add the term "near me." How your local agents show up is directly connected to how well their local digital presence is managed.

Are Your Local Agents Visible When Insurance Buyers Search?

Captive insurance carriers with a large network of local agents have an incredible opportunity to show up in local organic search results virtually for free, and alongside online-only competitors with massive digital marketing budgets. By optimizing for the five known controllable signals, local agents can increase organic search rank for important keywords like 'auto insurance,' and improve how frequently they appear in the Google 3-Pack, the first three organic search results.

This process, where multi-location businesses seek to improve how they rank on search engines that use the user's location to suggest nearby businesses is called Proximity Search Optimization (PSO). With MomentFeed's PSO platform, your agents will be able to manage the five known signals that determine local search rankings including:

  • Local Listings Accuracy: Information accuracy and consistency across all networks
  • Local Profile Completeness: All applicable fields filled out on each discovery network
  • Ratings and Reviews: High rating score and responsiveness to reviews
  • Local Facebook Publishing Activity: Frequency of posts on local social and ideal keyword density
  • On-Page Signals: Local agent page alignment with Google's assessment of quality

‍

Local Exclusive Agents Fail to Capitalized on Their Proximity to Millions of Local Buyers

To gain a better understanding of PSO performance and opportunity in the insurance industry, MomentFeed conducted a PSO audit of the top six U.S. captive insurance carriers. The audit found that the industry as a whole lacks maturity, and any insurance carrier willing to invest in a comprehensive PSO strategy, could dominate and see significant financial gains.

Insurance Proximity Search Optimization Report Card

Overall, insurance carriers did well on their location profile completeness, but there is room for improvement across every other category. Opportunity for improvement is particularly high in local social (Facebook) publishing, local listing accuracy, and ratings and reviews.

It is also telling that the highest rated carrier significantly outperforms its rivals in the Google 3-Pack despite receiving a mediocre grade of a B-. The opportunity becomes even more clear when you compare the six largest captive insurance carriers to a best in class MomentFeed client - this comparison demonstrates that the insurance industry lacks the level of sophistication seen elsewhere. The sample MomentFeed client earned an A- overall grade and ranks in the Google 3-Pack 97% of the time.

This lack of maturity leaves the door open for any carrier — even those which currently place in almost no locations in the Google 3-Pack — to quickly rise to the top should they implement a comprehensive PSO strategy.

Keep us in your search resultsAdd us as a preferred source on Google
g2 4.6 star rating reviews badge
capterra 4.6 star rating badge
software advice 4.6 star rating badge

1,800 brands trust us to stay visible

 — not just show up once or twice in local search.

Request a demo

Resources

You Might Also Find Interesting

GEO Studio screenshot
Blogs
Local AEO Marketing
Local Listings Management
Multi-Location SEO
How Do You Report on GEO Metrics When AI Models Agree on Less Than 6% of Local Business Recommendations?

A practical GEO analytics guide to the AI search metrics multi-location brands need to track, how to interpret your GEO dashboard, and what the numbers can't tell you yet.

mockup of store locator in Uberall platform
Blogs
Multi-Location SEO
Local AEO Marketing
How to Create a Store Locator Page That Google, ChatGPT, and Your Customers Can All Read

10 tips for building a store locator that Google, ChatGPT, and your customers can all read, starting with the test that shows what AI crawlers see.

woman on her phone with a mockup of AI results
Blogs
Multi-Location Marketing
Retail Brands
Local AEO Marketing
How to Get AI Tools to Recommend Your Black Friday Deals Across Locations

Get your locations ready for Black Friday. Boost visibility, engagement & conversions in the era of AI search with these smart local marketing tactics.

Woman on her phone with screenshots of Prompts in GEO Studio
Blogs
Multi-Location SEO
Local AEO Marketing
You Can Do Better Than Only Tracking “Best … Near Me” Prompts: 16 Intent Clusters for Local Keyword and Prompt Research

Local keywords aren't dead — but they're not enough. Learn how prompt research helps multi-location brands drive foot traffic from AI search.

woman laying down in bed with a screenshot of a local search in Google AI Mode
Blogs
Local Listings Management
Retail Brands
How to Optimize for the Season When Clicks to Your Website Are Down, But Retail Store Searches on Google Are Up 141%

93% of AI Mode impressions in retail generate zero outbound clicks — yet store searches are surging. Our proprietary data from 33,000 US locations reveals where the retail customer journey actually starts today, and what marketers should measure instead of website traffic.

mockup of negative review replys
Blogs
Business Review Management
Local AEO Marketing
Negative Reviews Aren’t Hurting Your Footfall, But Not Responding to Them Probably Is

AI models now read your review responses to decide whether to recommend your business. Here's how to respond to negative reviews in the AI search era — with templates, first-party data, and a framework for managing responses at scale.

laptop screen showing uberall local competitor intel
Blogs
Uberall Product Tips
UB-I Just Got Access to Your Full Analytics Suite — Here’s What You Can Ask It

UB-I can now answer questions about your performance data in plain language — reviews, listings, search rankings, GEO Pulse, and more.

person holding phone with AI icons around
Blogs
Local AEO Marketing
Local Listings Management
AI Search Optimization for Multi-Location Businesses — What We Learned from 11,705 AI Responses

AI search engines are reshaping how customers find local businesses. Here’s what multi-location brands need to optimize — and measure — to stay visible and recommended in AI-generated answers.

screenshot of GEO Studio with selecting prompts
Blogs
Local AEO Marketing
Multi-Location SEO
Most Brands Either Rush Their Prompt Set or Track Thousands They Never Look At — This Is How to Track AI Visibility as a Multi-Location Brand

We know that AI answers change every time you ask, so here are our recommendations on how to select and track a healthy prompt set in GEO Studio for multi-location brands.

People in the car looking at the map
Blogs
Local Listings Management
Apple for Business
Apple Maps Listings: Place Card Views Grew 30% Last Year — Here’s How to Make Sure Your Business Is Part of That

Find out how businesses that optimize their Apple Maps listings now will gain a solid advantage in a space most competitors haven’t even entered.

Previous
Next