Strawberry Rhubarb
Tart rhubarb combined with sweet strawberries baked in Polly's famous buttery & flaky pie crust.
USD5.29
Apple
Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices.
Slices of Pie
USD5.29
Apple made with Splenda
Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices. Made with Splenda sugar substitute.
Slices of Pie
USD5.49
Apple Crisp
Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices, covered with a sweet crumbly topping!
Slices of Pie
USD5.99
Banberry®
Ms. Polly's delicious banana cream filling, topped with fresh sweet strawberries and a ring of real whipped cream.
Slices of Pie
USD5.99
Banberry® made with Splenda
Ms. Polly's delicious banana cream filling made with Splenda sugar substitute, topped with fresh sweet strawberries and real whipped cream.
USD5.99
Banana Cream
Plump fresh bananas lavished in creamy vanilla custard and topped with whipped cream and almonds.
Slices of Pie
USD5.29
Banana Cream made with Splenda
Plump fresh bananas lavished in creamy vanilla custard with Splenda sugar substitute and topped with whipped cream.
USD5.49
Banoffee
Layers of caramel and velvety smooth banana cream filling, finished with our real whipped cream, a sprinkle of toffee bits, and a drizzle of caramel.
USD5.29
Boysenberry
Luscious boysenberries, chock full of tangy flavor.
Slices of Pie
USD6.49
Chocolate Cream
Deep rich chocolate, made from egg custard and cocoa, topped with whipped cream.
Slices of Pie
USD5.29
Cherry
Red, tart and juicy cherries from Utah or Michigan, captured in one of Polly's original pies.
Slices of Pie
USD5.29
Cherry made with Splenda
Red, tart and juicy cherries from Utah or Michigan, captured in one of Polly's original pies, made with Splenda sugar substitute.
USD5.49
Coconut Cream
The finest shredded Hawaiian Coconut is drenched in rich old-fashioned custard topped with whipped cream.
Slices of Pie
USD5.29
Chocolate Silk
Silky chocolate baked in our famous pie crust and topped with real whipped cream and chocolate shavings.
USD6.49
Custard
An old-fashioned egg custard, rich and creamy, spiced just right.
USD5.29
Lemon Meringue
Lots of tasty lemon filling with a mountain of toasted meringue.
Slices of Pie
USD5.29
